There's one thing we should address right off the bat, and that's that anyone who's been reanimated would have an impressive draw. That said, I don't think we can afford to ignore the spectacle element, at least for the purposes of BBFTDL (Brought Back from the Dead, LIVE!). Or to put it another way, I see nothing wrong in pitting some guy who has been reanimated against any of the usual suspects (Pink Floyd, Dylan, Holy Fuck/Pains of Being Pure at Heart double bill, etc.) in the future.
But for now, let's consider John Entwhistle. He's not been dead that long, so if he were to be reanimated for a tour so soon after dying, it might only arouse a comparable level of excitement as a day-of-show announcement for Sonic Youth at Maxwells--- the promoter is up against saturation in either case. At least from my point of view, it seemed that the Who was frequently giving concerts in the few years before John Entwhistle died, which again, was not that long ago. So that's a strike in my book. And what's more, I think if I were to be made aware that reanimation was possible, and for whatever reason they didn't reanimate Keith Moon, I would be royally pissed and might not go to the show purely out of resentment, regardless of what the alternative is.
///
Suppose though that my reaction to the Who lineup was not an adverse one, and that I was able to consider my choices objectively. Then what of the Julian Lennon substitution? ...It's unimpressive, at best. It's probably been pitched to Paul's people by so many promoters already that it may as well have already happened....at least when you consider it from a "thoughts are things"/New Age angle.
And I'm afraid to say the case is the same in the Eric Clapton/George Harrison department. He's probably guest appeared with all three Beatles so many times that the idea of a collaboration seems ho-hum to me. And furthermore, I think it was in poor taste to begin with that they opened the doors up at all to other musicians on their records. I would find it hard to believe that one of the Beatles or George Martin couldn't have performed what they ended up with from either Billy Preston or Eric Clapton. But more than anything else, it doesn't sit well with me that there exists in our lexicon the term "5th Beatle". If they'd stopped with the overdubs at George Martin, maybe we wouldn't have found the need for it. Anyway, my point is that Eric Clapton has to bear the brunt of this, so fuck him...he's out.
VERDICT: Beatles, by a slim margin...and that isn't saying much. After all, it is The Beatles we're talking about. I bet Paul McCartney could draw a mean crowd just to watch him play a couple games of "Rock Band".
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I fancy bit of logic that can not easily be disputed. I praise the supposition, the investigation, and the conclusion. One does ponder this, "Could the destroyed instruments of the Who also be reanimated and how might that effect the delicate balance of the equation?"
ReplyDeleteNot sure, that's outside my area of expertise.
ReplyDelete